19 comments

  • Eduardo Ramirez HolguinEduardo Ramirez Holguin, almost 9 years ago

    Wish account requirement was just for posting not voting.

    12 points
  • Oz LozanoOz Lozano, almost 9 years ago

    damn. this is addictive.

    7 points
  • Mike HeitzkeMike Heitzke, almost 9 years ago

    This isn't A/B testing. Not even a little.

    It fills a small void with the departure of http://www.polarb.com/ but this is hardly scientific.

    5 points
    • Rob Gill, almost 9 years ago

      Not sure I agree? Of course it can be used as A/B testing. It doesn't have to be a scientific experiment to getting a quick opinion from the community.

      I agree with the other point, a bit of a rip off of http://www.polarb.com/ but like how it's aimed at the design community so you get validated feedback.

      Also reminded me of http://scorem.co.uk which again is like polar but aimed at a specific audience, football fans.

      0 points
      • Mitch Malone, almost 9 years ago

        A/B tests are intended to evaluate a design. If you have two designs and want to see which results in higher conversions, for example, you would instrument a deploy so 50% of your customers see Design A and 50% see Design B. Then you measure the conversion rate. The user doesn't see both designs. A/B tests aren't exactly scientific either but it's data you can use to inform another design.

        Desinion is more of a feedback tool using a polling convention similar to Polar, from my estimation. This is not to say that the site isn't useful; just wanted to clarify what A/B testing is. :D

        8 points
      • Mike HeitzkeMike Heitzke, almost 9 years ago

        Naturally, my initial comment was a bit terse. I didn't mean to diminish the value of getting quick voting style feedback.

        It's just not really the equivalent of a/b testing. We're not subjecting unsuspecting users to an A or B experience and evaluating various outcomes and measures here. Simply asking people (designers probably) for a quick gut check.

        I dig your dinosaur avatar btw :)

        2 points
        • Rob Gill, almost 9 years ago

          Yea I know mate, I just wanted to start the conversation. Having a whalely good debate with you... :/

          2 points
  • David BarkerDavid Barker, almost 9 years ago (edited almost 9 years ago )

    I like it!

    It's a shame passwords can't be longer than 15 characters, though.

    3 points
  • Jeremy WellsJeremy Wells, almost 9 years ago

    This is definitely not "A/B Testing"

    2 points
  • Vinay ChilukuriVinay Chilukuri, almost 9 years ago

    It is A/B testing only if you test something in context. This is what the site advertises it to be.. just an opinion gatherer.

    1 point
  • Shawn BorskyShawn Borsky, almost 9 years ago

    Weirdly addictive. I just did about 20 of them and I have work to do!

    0 points
  • Daniel GuestDaniel Guest, almost 9 years ago

    Good idea but having played with it for a few minutes I couldn't help but think, 'I wish there was some serious work on here I could really think about.'

    0 points
  • Jim SilvermanJim Silverman, almost 9 years ago

    tagline sucks, but the app is actually great.

    0 points
  • Tim Wilkins, almost 9 years ago

    Good idea.

    0 points
  • Matthew RoundellMatthew Roundell, almost 9 years ago

    Pointless.

    -1 points