11 comments

  • David BachmannDavid Bachmann, almost 9 years ago

    This looks... bad. But hey thanks for the heads up!

    3 points
  • Juan VelascoJuan Velasco, almost 9 years ago

    Am I the only one that's annoyed by the fact that they treat input fields, buttons, headings, prompts... exactly the same way? No hierarchy or differentiation at all, just style for style sake —and it doesn't even look good.

    2 points
    • Samuel HulickSamuel Hulick, almost 9 years ago

      I definitely thought it was an... interesting choice. As a user, I was confused at several points, but I guess you could also say it was memorable & distinctive.

      0 points
  • Rob AlanRob Alan, almost 9 years ago

    Yet another nice teardown!

    The password recovery setup process is different and takes care of some back and forth, but I have to say it seems clunky to me. Maybe because it's so out of the blue? You go from allowing push notifications straight to that email screen. Quite jolting—although I'll be honest, I have not tried YOing, myself.

    2 points
    • Samuel HulickSamuel Hulick, almost 9 years ago

      I actually tried signing up twice, and the email confirmation step came at two different points -- I think it was triggered on a timer, not an action. Still weird though.

      I also wonder if people with multiple addresses will have a hard time remembering which address was used if/when the time for pw recovery comes around, but at least it's less immediately intrusive than sending them out of the app completely!

      1 point
  • Samuel HulickSamuel Hulick, almost 9 years ago

    Hi all! I created this teardown, so any questions or feedback are gladly accepted right here -- please fire away!

    2 points
    • Tad MilbournTad Milbourn, almost 9 years ago

      Just wanted to say this is the 3rd or 4th of these teardowns that I've come across of yours...and I love them. So useful and actionable to see and apply to our own projects.

      Keep them coming!

      Also, for such a simple app, I was surprised to see how confusing their signup process was. I would have thought there would be an ability to use it without an account...where you could just choose to have certain services "Yo" you.

      2 points