How do I get all FontAwesome fonts to work in Sketch?

9 years ago from , Product Designer @ Lyft

I have Font Awesome installed on my computer and am using the cheat sheet to transfer icons to mockups in Sketch from Bohemian Coding, but unfortunately, not all icons are rendering correctly. Chevrons appear as they do in the cheat sheet, but other icons, such as the anchor, do not. They appear as a box with an X in the middle.

Font in Sketch is set to Font Awesome so I'm not sure what's going on and why some icons will render correctly and others look like a box with an X.

Anyone else face this problem and solve it? Insights are much appreciated!