Designer News
Where the design community meets.
almost 9 years ago from Jonathan Levy, Product Developer @revealparis
Apples and oranges, friend. Invision is an excellent prototyping tool, while Framer is an interaction design tool that allows you to create custom animations and interactions after you've already prototyped your application.
I wouldn't say apples and oranges, I'd say apples and ripe apples.
Also, framer.js says "Prototyping" in their main page title.
I understand how different the output of these two tools could be, but I also see a huge slice of users using them for basically the same thing: showing a "working" prototype to a person who isn't technical enough to "picture it".
Apples and pears? :S
While they're definitely both for prototyping, Framer is more aimed at prototyping animation and not the overall flow of the application.
I don't personally use Framer (anymore), but the way it fit into my workflow was more of a designer-shows-the-developer kind of thing. I typically used Invision to show a client how their website or app will function, and get sign off on completed designs. To me, they are very different.
If you've got a designer that's using Framer with success, I'd love to hire him/her. Seriously, designers are using CoffeeScript to show a developer how they want things coded?
I guess that's why Framer doesn't seem to fit into the flow for me— no designer I know would be able to use it unassisted.
(unless that designer wears all the hats)
I guess some would consider me one of those rare "unicorn" designers who codes, hand letters, produces icon sets, and can wireframe with the best of them, so I'm definitely not above learning CoffeeScript if it will help improve my finished product. At some point or another, I've used Framer, After Effects, Quartz, Origami with Quartz and Keynote to animate. I personally prefer After Effects but it has its drawbacks.
Lately I've been fortunate enough to worth with a developer in which all I have to do is provide him an AE interaction prototype and he can bang out the animation without much further input from me.
As far as those who wear all the hats, we're everywhere. We just mostly freelance (though I opt not to. I can't find a bizdev hat that fits me well enough).
I wear all the above hats and still find it hard to believe there is a large section of designers using this tool properly.
I guess it all depends on what you consider a "large section of designers", and what you think that means in relation to the tool. Example: a "large section of designers" don't even know HTML, and that doesn't make it a bad tool, does it?
Anyway, this is from Framer's site:
(The list is far from complete, judging from the amount of designers from other big companies that we've interacted with during the last months while working on the Sketch integration : )
Designer News
Where the design community meets.
Designer News is a large, global community of people working or interested in design and technology.
Have feedback?
Jeez I guess it's almost time for me to learn coffeescript. I know the results will be worth it, but I simply can't imagine anything being any quicker than InVision.